The Russiaville Methodist Church was established in the 1840’s when a number of early settlers from Ohio, Southern Indiana and the Southeastern states were coming into the township to set up permanent homes.
Among these rugged pioneers were the Ratcliffs, Dixonns, Wilsons, Floyds, Lambs, Jeters and Fortner who followed Joseph Taylor the first white man to come to the Russiaville area.
Russiaville’s early residents were intent upon establishing religious and education as soon as they were settled. Those of the Methodist faith opened their homes for meetings, the first of what was held in the home of Solomon and Benoni Fortner. Sermons were heard only occasionally when a circuit minister happened along.
In 1861, the Order of Odd Fellows Lodge and the Methodist people erected a two story building on the site of the present Methodist church. The lodge used the upper story and the Methodist people used the lower floor. In 1881 a foundation was put under the building to keep the hogs out from under it. On an early Sunday morning, April 27, 1902, the church burned to the ground.
In 1903 the Lodge deeded their half of the property to Frankin Fortner, who gave it to the church. The contract for the new building was for $5300. On Sunday, October 11, 1903, dedication services were held. This structure and all its contents burned on the evening of January 9, 1942 with an estimated loss of $40, to $50,000.
The congregation used the Russiaville school building from January 1942 until September 1942 at which time the services were transferred the the John Burress residence on East Main Street. This home was located where the east end of Stout’s Funeral Home now stands. (This home had been left to the church in the Burress estate). Services were held there until the property was sold February 12, 1946, at which time the congregation moved back to the school. Because of the war, much delay and difficulty was endured before a new building could be erected. But on Sunday evening June 16, 1946, the first preaching service was held in a colonial styled brick church.
On Sunday evening, April 11, 1965, at about service time, a tornado leveled a large part of town. The Methodist church was damaged, but not destroyed. After a week services were resumed in spite of the rubble. The Christian Church congregation, and the Baptist Church Congregation also held their services in the Methodist Church.
While the damage was being repaired, some redesigning was also being done. The steeple was changed and also the front of the sanctuary.
On Christmas morning 2000, this building was burned to the ground and was replaced with the present structure, two years later, a the total price of $1,300,000. The first service was held July 15, 2002.
On May 8, 2008, a service was held for the burning of the mortgage. This current building lends itself greatly for use by the community. Western Buddy Bags are packed here, a community food pantry is also housed in this building and the Community Vacation Bible School. Several other groups utilize the building because of its accessibility.